In November 1915, Avon's library was a single rented room on Main Street. Valerie Penrose of Philadelphia and Frances Winans of Allenhurst, two women who spent their summers in Avon, went to New York to ask the Carnegie Foundation for a building. They were turned down because the town was too small. They went back and explained that Avon's population grew enormously every summer. The Foundation granted $5,000. According to The Coaster's account of the library's 110th anniversary, the borough had 707 year-round residents at the time, which made Avon the smallest town in the United States to receive Carnegie funding.
That building still stands at Fifth and Garfield Avenues. It is one of four Carnegie library buildings in Monmouth County and one of 19 in New Jersey. This fall it is also one of several working buildings where Avon's history is on display. The town has no museum to keep that history in, so the exhibits are in the library, the post office and the school.
A Historical Society Without a Room of Its Own
The Avon-by-the-Sea Historical Society has an extensive artifact collection and no permanent place to show it. In September and October it ran a survey asking residents to support a request to the borough for a museum. In the meantime, its fall displays are spread across three public buildings:
- Avon Post Office, 321 Main Street: The History of the Avon Lifeguards, through December 31.
- Avon Library: The History of the Avon Free Public Library, September 1 through December 31.
- Avon School: The History of the Shark River, for students and staff only, through December 31.
The lifeguard exhibit is a good example of what these displays add. The Coaster reported that the borough hires 60 lifeguards each summer, 45 full-time and the rest part-time, to cover roughly three-quarters of a mile of beach. This summer's oldest guard was 63, and he has worked Avon's beach since high school. The early history was messier. After the Avon pool was built in 1905, the Avon Beach Company leased the operation, and guarding the beach became a long dispute between the company and the town. The company refused to supply guards, ropes and boats because pool patrons were swimming on the guarded beach without paying the pool fee.
The pool from that story is also a stop on the borough's walking tour.
The Ten Stops, Grouped by Where They Stand
The borough's Historical Stroll Walkabout Tour is a permanent set of 10 signs, each with a QR code that plays a short video. The Historical Society built it with John Flannagan of My Local History. Society members supplied photos and histories, and Flannagan and Society president Norah Magrini edited the videos and signs together. It was dedicated on July 2, 2026, and Netta Radice Designs designed the brochure and map. Paper maps are at the Avon Borough Office and the Avon Library.
The stops fall into four clusters, which makes it easy to walk the tour in pieces:
- Main Street at the municipal complex. The Fire Department at 301 Main Street dates its founding to 1901, and its first firehouse was on Norwood Avenue. The Train Depot stop is on the same site. Rail service reached the area in 1876, the depot opened by 1883 and the building was removed in 1967. The First Aid Squad, also on Main Street, formed in 1931, and its early ambulance was a converted hearse.
- Woodland Avenue. St. John's Episcopal Church began as a summer chapel in 1883. The Avon Water Tower stands at the top of Woodland, west of Main Street by the railroad. It went up in the 1920s after voters rejected a proposed municipal water plant.
- Fifth Avenue. This cluster has the library at Garfield, Avon Grammar School at 505 Lincoln Avenue and Fifth, which began in 1908 as a two-room school, and St. Elizabeth's Catholic Church at Fifth and Lincoln, incorporated in 1907 and later rebuilt as a Gothic stone church.
- Ocean Avenue. The Columns at 601 Ocean Ave N began in 1883 as Berwick Lodge and later served as a hotel, a restaurant and a rooming house. Next door, the pool at 609 Ocean Avenue reopened as a freshwater pool in 1961, and its water ballet started in 1975.
The Post Office exhibit at 321 Main Street is a short walk from the first cluster, so the lifeguard display and the Ocean Avenue pool stop make a natural pair.
The Lawn at 301 Main Street Gets Its Newest Layer
The first cluster sits on the busiest civic ground in town, and in November it gets busier.
On Veterans Day, Wednesday, November 11, at 11 a.m., the borough and the Historical Society will dedicate the Veterans and Fallen Heroes Monument Park on the municipal building lawn. The Coast Star reported that a new Vietnam Memorial is being added beside the historic WWI and WWII monuments, along with a pathway, landscaping and new lighting. The Avon School, the police department and the fire department are all taking part, and the borough has invited veterans and the public to attend. In the same Coast Star report, Mayor Edward Bonanno said veterans have been invited to a procession leading them to the park, with remarks from several of them, including retired general Tom Cosentino.
The Historical Society is collecting letters of thanks to veterans through Monday, November 9. Mail them to P.O. Box 23, Avon, NJ 07717.
Two and a half weeks later, the same building hosts the Avon Holiday Tree Lighting on Saturday, November 28, at 4:45 p.m. By Thanksgiving weekend, the old train depot site, the firehouse, the new memorial park and the town's holiday tree will all share one block of Main Street.
The Houses Are Not on the Map
The ten stops are public buildings, but much of Avon's history is in its private homes. In October, the Historical Society gave its first Janice Scrabis Preservation Awards, named for a lifelong resident and collector of Avon history, to two families who had restored their houses. The Coaster reported that one home, on Garfield Avenue, was built in 1905 by Dr. Ferdinand Angeny, a town doctor and council member. The other, on Ocean Avenue, is 139 years old and was built as a summer cottage by Reverend Robert Innes and his wife Helen of Philadelphia. In the 1897 local directory it was listed as the Gladys Cottage. Both are private residences.
The award will be given every year. Magrini told The Coaster that the winners were not nominated. The Society picked them because their restorations finished toward the end of the summer, and she is already watching a few homes now under renovation as possible winners next year.
"The homes built at this time were located near the ocean on Norwood, Woodland and Sylvania Avenues. There are also original homes on Main Street between Sylvania and Norwood Avenues."
She dates that building to 1883, when town founder Edward Batchelor built the Avon Inn and the Columns and building lots went up for sale. Families then built larger summer homes they called cottages. The Columns, one of the tour's Ocean Avenue stops, is one of those first 1883 buildings.
What the Route Looks Like This Winter
Parts of the walk run past active work.
On Ocean Avenue, the promenade and bulkhead extension has been under construction since July 6. Catel is the contractor, and the project is funded through the New Jersey Boardwalk Preservation Fund. At the Sylvan Lake Joint Commission's October 21 meeting, the work was reported as on schedule. According to the borough's October 13 minutes, Public Works expects to do substantial sand-moving on the beachfront after December 1, so the beach end of the Ocean Avenue cluster will look different in December than it does now.
The borough's October 13 meeting minutes include a few other things for anyone walking or parking near the stops:
- Garfield Avenue paving had an anticipated start date of October 19, which puts it on the library's street.
- A new accessible entrance to the Municipal Building was set to begin within two to four weeks of that meeting.
- The police report at that meeting said parallel parking is back in effect on First and Second Avenues and that dogs are permitted on the beach but must be leashed.
The Living Shoreline on the Avon side of Sylvan Lake is also worth a look. Phases one and two are done, and phase three is now scheduled for spring 2027. The plans include a ramp near Fourth Avenue for winter skating access.
The Dates Between Now and December 31
- Monday, November 9: Last day to mail letters of thanks for veterans to P.O. Box 23. The Historical Society also meets that evening at 6:30 p.m. at the Avon Marina, 2 Main Street, and all are welcome.
- Wednesday, November 11, 11 a.m.: Dedication of the Veterans and Fallen Heroes Monument Park, municipal building lawn.
- Saturday, November 28, 4:45 p.m.: Avon Holiday Tree Lighting at the Municipal Building.
- Tuesday, December 8, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.: The Historical Society's Annual Vintage/Costume Jewelry Sale at the Avon Marina Building.
- Thursday, December 31: Last day for the lifeguard exhibit at the Post Office and the library history display.
The QR signs are permanent. The exhibits inside the Post Office and the library come down at the end of the year, and the library's new historical marker, paid for with a $2,000 grant from the G. William Pomeroy Foundation, will stay at Fifth and Garfield.
If you walk the stroll this season and start wondering about the history of your own Avon house, or of the block you live on, I'm always glad to compare notes on the town's older homes. You can reach me any time through Carly Ringer. Let's Connect.